How to Approach a Genealogy Mystery with Just a Few Clues

As I browsed in an antique store one weekend, the two faces jumped out of me. That wasn’t an easy task since the card they appeared on was virtually hidden in a locked glass cabinet tucked inside a yellowed plastic envelope, and a 1950s envelope obscured part of the card. When I got someone to unlock the cabinet so I could take a look my first thought was that S. Ada Miller had to be a woman and that this might be a political campaign piece for a woman seeking to be elected at about the time of the 19th amendment.

How to Approach a Genealogy Mystery with Just a Few Clues

The card shows two children and states “Two Reasons why I am a candidate for the office of county recorder. S Ada Miller. Ames Iowa.”

Post-it 1

Post-it 2

On the back, the antique dealer wrote on a small post-it note that she had found an S. Ada Miller in the 1913 Record of the Great Council of Iowa-Degree of Pocahontas “she is listed as Great Keeper of Records.”

Quite frankly at $3.00 it was worth a risk to purchase it and learn more to satisfy my curiosity.

How Do You Start?

How do you start to research someone that you only have a few clues for? Well, first you note what clues you do have. In this case I knew:

  • Her name was S. Ada Miller or perhaps she went by Ada Miller
  • She was a woman (remember the antique dealer had already Googled her name and found her in a fraternal society, more on that below)
  • She possibly had 2 children (though it could be her grandchildren or some other relation)
  • She lived in Iowa (though maybe not Ames so I need keep that in mind)
  • She possibly was alive in the early 1900s judging from the photos.
  • She ran for a county government position and possibly held that position.

So what do I not know and have research questions about?

  • What did the “S” in her name stand for and did she ever go by that name or simply Ada?
  • What time period did she live in?
  • Was Miller a married name? If so, what is her husband’s name?
  • Are the two children pictured her children, another relation, or just children with no relationship to her?
  • Did she live in Ames, Iowa?
  • Did she become a County Recorder?
  • Why did she run for County Recorder (the card gives a possible clue)
  • Can I learn more about this item?

Now that I’ve identified what I know and my research questions, I need to start considering where to research. An obvious first step is to conduct a search on a genealogy website and see if I can locate her in the U.S. Census. If I can find her, that might confirm if she had children, a spouse, her approximate age, and where she lived. It might also give me an occupation. However, it’s not uncommon to find working women listed as a “housewife” in the census so I can’t make an assumption that the census will help with occupation.

Once I find her in the census and get that information I can then move on to other sources. For example, I should look for:

  • Vital Records (for her and possible children)
  • City Directories
  • Burial
  • Government Records (that might confirm her work if she was elected)

Because she ran for a city government position, I should expect to find her listed in newspapers. So I need to look for articles about her in online newspaper websites. I would also look in digitized books for possible local and family histories, directories, county reports, and other location-specific items.

Besides possibly being involved in government I know that the antique dealer found her name in a book or other records for the “Great Council of Iowa – Degree of Pocahontas.” The dealer didn’t say where this information comes from and I still need to verify this find. I’m assuming that the Degree of Pocahontas is referring to the female auxiliary to the fraternal order, the Improved Order of Red Men. This may mean additional records and at the least, it provides social context to her life. It also may mean she was married and her husband was in the Improved Order of Red Men fraternal order.

I can also expand my search by learning more about resources in Iowa by consulting the FamilySearch Research Wiki as well as specifically look in the FamilySearch Catalog for Iowa and the county for Ames, Iowa (Story). I do know that I will need to check:

  • Digitized newspaper websites
  • Genealogy websites
  • FamilySearch Catalog (and the Historical Records collection as well as the Digital Book Library)
  • Google Books

Before I start researching what else should I consider? Anything missing? What would you check? I’m interested in your thoughts and ideas.

In Part 2 we delve deeper into the case of S. Ada Miller.


Gena Philibert-Ortega is an author, instructor, and researcher. She blogs at Gena’s Genealogy and Food.Family.Ephemera. You can find her presentations on the Legacy Family Tree Webinars website.


Source: Legacy News

Posted On: May 21, 2021 at 11:15AM